Doggone by D. M. Buckley — A Sharp, Humorous Entry into Amateur Sleuth Fiction
Doggone, the first installment in D. M. Buckley’s Lexi O’Malley series, introduces readers to an unconventional heroine navigating danger with wit, improvisation, and more nerve than preparation. Lexi O’Malley is a thirty-two-year-old software programmer whose life has stalled—out of work, out of money, and uncertain of her next move. When her eccentric Aunt Scarlet pressures her into helping search for Bubba, a missing and none-too-bright black Labrador, Lexi reluctantly steps into a role she never imagined for herself.
What begins as a reluctant family obligation quickly escalates into a chaotic chain of events involving violence, deception, arson, and criminal pursuit. Lexi is not a trained investigator, nor is she particularly fearless. Instead, Buckley equips her with observational instincts, sharp sarcasm, and an impressive ability to lie convincingly when circumstances demand it. This imperfect competence grounds the story and gives the character a relatable edge.
Tonally, Doggone balances humor and suspense with confidence. The novel leans heavily on Lexi’s internal monologue to deliver comedy, while maintaining enough real danger to keep the stakes credible. The pacing is brisk and reader-friendly, making the book easy to move through without feeling lightweight or disposable. Mystery elements unfold gradually, rewarding readers who enjoy guessing alongside the protagonist.
The supporting cast—particularly Aunt Scarlet—adds color and eccentricity, while the Florida setting contributes a casual, sunlit contrast to the darker moments of violence and pursuit. Some readers may notice minor editorial inconsistencies or rough edges in continuity, but these do little to undermine the book’s entertainment value or narrative momentum.
Importantly, Doggone understands exactly what kind of story it wants to be. It does not aim for literary gravity or psychological depth; instead, it delivers a fast-paced, humorous mystery driven by character voice and escalating circumstance. As a series opener, it successfully establishes tone, character, and premise, encouraging readers to continue with Lexi O’Malley’s misadventures.
